An analysis of racially based pretextual traffic stops

In addition, regulation developed from within the organization might result in higher compliance by those who have to follow the rules—police officers themselves. By presenting police with objective numbers of who is really committing crime and at what rates, police may be more receptive to changing their practices and behaviors, rather than simply charging them with being racists, which does nothing but put them on the defensive and close opportunities to dialogue on the issue.

Numerous interviews, studies, and statistics have shown that racial profiling through the use of traffic stops is a real problem. United States, U. The common response seemed to implicate the police as racist, but some commentators, such as Kelley, noted the difficulty in parsing the situation.

The results showed that black drivers were three times more likely to be subjected to investigatory stops than whites, compared to clear traffic law violation stops, which showed no significant difference between blacks and whites.

Distrust and the Delegitimization of Law Enforcement While the negative effects of racial profiling is often presented in terms of arrest and incarceration rates, the social and psychological aspects of being a target of the police should not go overlooked.

Even without any reasonable suspicion or probable cause of another crime, the officer has the discretion to ask a person for consent and so long as it is voluntary, it is fully constitutional. Overall findings indicated that some minorities African Americans, Hispanics, and Native Americans were more likely to be pulled over than Whites and Asians.

Simmons, supra, at 41— The Nature of the Traffic Stop The routine traffic stop for blacks consists of multiple layers. If the person does refuse consent, police may still summon a drug-sniffing dog to detect narcotics in the vehicle. You say you did use your turn signal to change lanes? The policeman pulls up behind you.

Driving While Black: Racial Profiling and Traffic Stops

In Kansas City, a study was conducted where 2, drivers were surveyed regarding traffic stops. In addition, blacks The bill would have required the collection of data on each traffic stop conducted, including among others the race of the driver, whether a search was conducted, and the reason for the search, if there was one.

Very often, particularly at night, and when the vehicles are driving quickly, this is not the case. Moreover, this research suggests that targeting African-Americans yields no more drug courier arrests than random searches would.

Although policies that affect population growth would be questionable, policy makers and police organizations should make genuine efforts to reduce profiling by scrutinizing pretextual stops more closely, revising racial profiling forms to reflect more explicit police activity, taking away the ability for officers to make easy outstanding warrant and traffic violation arrests, and requiring documentation of departmental responses to disproportionate stop rates to accompany yearly racial profiling reports to the Attorney General.

If federal and local legislation fails, police departments could collect this data without first being told to do so. You have just been detained and possibly searched because someone did not like the looks of you.

Not every cop has to pull over every motorist who commits a minor traffic violation, and most cops probably do not. New testing devices designed to eliminate applicants who show racist tendencies, or the potential for developing racist tendencies, should be implemented.

United States, U. But if the police have some hunch that a person is suspicious, they will use a minor traffic violation to pull that person over and see whether their hunch is correct.

If police use statistically accurate data on who is really committing crime, they can stop relying on ingrained stereotypical, racist, and prejudicial views of blacks.

A study by Matthew D. Pretextual traffic stops do nothing more than aggravate feelings of injustice and inferiority, which results in the distrust of law enforcement and lack of faith in the entire justice system. Training and education programs should be comprehensive in scope and should be mandated not just at the initial training stages for new officers but should continue throughout their careers.

The petitioners challenged their convictions on the grounds that the stop and subsequent drug seizure was unconstitutional. Negative Effects of Racial Profiling A. To achieve a comprehensive solution to the problem legislation is needed to mandate reporting of traffic stop data.

Essentially, what is needed is more intelligent and cost-efficient means of catching crime, which will in turn of course, cut back on racial profiling.The Illinois data is available on the Internet and includes an analysis of traffic stops throughout the state.

Overall findings indicated that some minorities (African Americans, Hispanics, and Native Americans) were more likely to. Pretextual stops based on race, known as Driving While Black [DWB], is a common phenomenon which occurs when police, with a “legitimate” reason, pull over blacks when the real reason for the stop is influenced by a prejudiced, stereotyped, and.

Pretextual traffic stops have come to the fore in questions of police suspicion because, like mobile data terminal queries (Meehan & Ponder, ), they are expected to be more discretionary in. Pretextual stops based on advantages disadvantages having children essay discretion in a racially biased include calling for mandatory collection and analysis of traffic stops and for better.

· PRETEXTUAL TRAFFIC STOPS: A pretextual traffic stop involves a settlement action an analysis of racially based pretextual traffic stops. Feb 02,  · Since there is no study or data that supports the view that racial minorities violate traffic laws in any greater number than whites, one would expect that traffic stops in Philadelphia would be largely consistent with the census race data, and that no more than percent of the stops would be of African Americans and roughly no more.

An analysis of racially based pretextual traffic stops

Other variables that might explain pretextual stops and traffic stop outcomes, including violent crime rates and socioeconomic differences between the Black and White populations, are assessed. The study finds support for the minority group threat hypothesis in explaining racial profiling based on the relative growth and size of the .

Download
An analysis of racially based pretextual traffic stops
Rated 5/5 based on 28 review